Piano Concerto on the Planets Premieres – Sky & Telescope

Advertisements

Move over, Gustav Holst. There’s a new Planets in town. And this one is based on astronomy, not astrology.

Holst’s seven-movement orchestral suite The Planets premiered in London in 1918. Now, a little more than a century later, a modern version on the theme saw first light on Sunday May 22, 2022. But while Holst turned to astrology for inspiration, composer Daniel Perttu turned to astronomy.

Genesis of A Planets Odyssey

Pianist Jeffrey Biegel’s longtime dream was to bring to life an updated version of Holst’s The Planets, infusing the music with current scientific understanding. Biegel was born deaf, and until the age of three, when corrective surgery allowed him to hear for the first time, his world was very closed. He relied on other means of expression and communication, and so music became his first language. As a result, his projects often have an “out of the box” element. Biegel’s vision of a revamped Planets features the pianist as a space traveler journeying through the solar system.

Pianist Jeffrey Biegel and Composer Daniel Perttu
Pianist Jeffrey Biegel (faculty member at the Conservatory of Music at Brooklyn College) and composer Daniel Perttu (Professor of Music Theory and Composition at Westminster College) teamed up to produce A Planets Odyssey. Shortly after meeting Perttu (at the behest of a mutual acquaintance), Biegel realized that he’d found the person who could help bring his project to fruition. Perttu loved the idea, and so the pair embarked on their collaboration.
Jerry LoFaro / Derek D. Buck

A Planets Odyssey isn’t your typical three-movement concerto. Instead, it’s in a theme-and-variations form. “It begins with the Big Bang, followed by the pianist introducing the main theme of the concerto,” Perttu explains. “This theme is then varied as the pianist visits each planet and is inspired by the unique properties of each planet.” Like Holst, Perttu skips the Earth. But unlike Holst, these planets are featured in their order from the Sun. And more importantly, Perttu focuses solely on the science.

Pianist as Cosmic Traveler

Perttu picked a few characteristics of each planet for inspiration and transformed those into sonic visions. For example, Mercury, subject of the first variation, is the innermost and smallest of the solar system’s planets and experiences extremes in temperature. It also has virtually no atmosphere. So Perttu drew on those characteristics to produce a variation that conveys the imagery of a “stark, extreme kind of place.”

Holst crater on Mercury
Mercury is an airless world, its surface pockmarked by craters, ridges, and lava plains – scars indicating a violent past. The planet’s craters are named after artists, authors, and musicians; in fact, Holst has his own 170-kilometer-wide crater, pictured here!
NASA / Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory / Carnegie Institution of Washington

Venus is the brightest object in the night sky, apart from the Moon and the Sun. Its atmosphere is largely roiling clouds of carbon dioxide. At the planet’s surface, where temperatures reach a whopping 470 ° C (870 ° F), the pressure is some 90 times that of Earth’s. At some point in its early, cooler history, Venus may have had a shallow liquid-water ocean and may have harbored life, but that’s all long gone by now. The prospect of potential current or past life is always thrilling, and that’s the angle that sonically describes Venus in this variation.

Rounding out the rocky planets, March continues to capture our imagination, with its dusty red surface and the solar system’s biggest volcano. Perttu nevertheless reads a sadness in Mars’s story. A planet that once may have had a lush environment with liquid water on its surface – and perhaps life – is today instead a cold and arid world.

When we get to the gas giants, Perttu introduces a sense of airiness to the music. First comes majestic Jupiter, the largest planet in the solar system, rich in hydrogen and helium. It is famous for its Great Red Spot, which is, in fact, one humongous storm that has raged for more than 300 years. The Great Red Spot and other storms on Jupiter are also sites of lightning! In fact, Perttu describes this passage as “swirly, blustery, and sometimes tempestuous.”

Shallow lightning on Jupiter
NASA’s Juno mission captured these images of breaks in Jupiter’s cloud deck through which we glimpse deep into the planet’s atmosphere. JunoCam caught shallow lightningor high-altitude electrical discharges, associated with active storms.
NASA / JPL-Caltech / SwRI / MSSS / Image processing: Brian Swift @ CC BY

Ask most any astronomer what drew them to the subject, and the answer – more often than not – is their first view of Saturn through a telescope. The sight of the ethereal planet with its system of rings is inspiring at every level. But to add to the planet’s attraction, we now know that its atmosphere contains diamonds. And not only that, but that the diamonds might fall as rain! Hence, Saturn’s variation is “slower but shimmery in its sensibility.”

William Herschel discovered Uranus in 1781. The ice giant’s atmosphere is largely hydrogen and helium, with traces of methane that give the planet its eerie, greenish hue (by absorbing the red wavelengths of light). Uranus is a planet with a quirk: A cataclysmic interaction with another body in the early solar system tipped it over on its side with respect to its orbital plane, so instead of orbiting the Sun like the other planets, it rolls along in its orbit. Because of this, Perttu has inverted the main theme in the variation, as well as infusing it with a dark, dismal sentiment.

Perttu composed the eighth variation to reflect a sense of windiness since the last of our planets, Neptune, is the windiest of them all. The blue ice giant, the most distant of all planets (more than 30 times the Earth-Sun distance), is dark and cold, and supersonic winds rage through its atmosphere at speeds greater than 2,000 km / h (1,200 mph). For comparison, the fastest winds recorded on Earth clock at at around 400 km / h.

Hubble Space Telescope image of Neptune
The Hubble Space Telescope snapped this shot of the solar system’s most distant planet, the ice giant Neptune. The dark spots are huge storms that formed on the windy planet. The larger of the two storms (at left) is wider than Earth’s Atlantic Ocean.
NASA / ESA / STScI / MH Wong (University of California, Berkeley) / LA Sromovsky and PM Fry (University of Wisconsin-Madison)

And in a neat final touch, we end our odyssey all the way out in the Kuiper Belt. Of course, when Holst composed The Planets, Pluto and other distant solar system objects hadn’t yet been discovered. But in a fitting coda to A Planets OdysseyPerttu brings us to the very outer edges of our solar system.

And now. . . the music

On Sunday May 22, 2022, in the evening, the Canton Symphony Orchestra (lead commissioning orchestra in a consortium of multiple orchestras) ushered A Planets Odyssey into the world, under the direction of the Orchestra’s Music Director, Gerhardt Zimmermann. Biegel was at the piano.

“Today is tomorrow’s history,” Biegel said after the concert. “There is a unique energy in the room when all the stars align to witness the birth of a new creation – Dan’s A Planets Odyssey created a synergy of musical, spiritual, and scientific energies igniting the hearts and minds of the audience and the performers. ” He concludes, “It is a feeling which joins us in a historic moment like no other.”

Perttu was also philosophical following the concert. “Writing this piece was not only about creating a musical representation of our scientific knowledge of the planets in 2020, but it was also about how science can inspire imagination,” he mused. “Who would have thought of diamond rain ?! There are mysteries in this universe that likely go beyond our most fantastic speculation – and this piece is meant to capture that spirit as well. ”

Daniel Perttu, Gerhardt Zimmermann, Jeffrey Biegel at opening night of A Planets Odyssey
Perttu, Zimmermann, and Biegel beam after a successful and joyous performance. Now that the premiere is behind them, they can relax!
Jeffrey Biegel

After the thrill of Sunday evening, Biegel notes that the journey does not end there. He envisions “that A Planets Odyssey will serve the purposes of music, science and education for students learning about our solar system. ”


If you’re in the Flagstaff, Arizona, area in September 2022, make sure you catch the next performance of A Planets Odyssey by the Flagstaff Symphony Orchestra conducted by Music Director Charles Latshaw, with Jeffrey Biegel as piano soloist.


Advertisement